Neurolaw, Nemo Tenetur, dan Batas Konstitusional Pembacaan Aktivitas Neural dalam Proses Pidana

Neurolaw, Nemo Tenetur, Neural Activity, Criminal Evidence, The New Code of Criminal Procedure, Mental Privacy.

Authors

7 November 2026
7 November 2026

The enactment of Law Number 20 of 2025 on the Indonesian Code of Criminal Procedure serves as an important point of entry for reassessing the constitutional limits of criminal evidence in light of advances in science and technology. The new Code of Criminal Procedure is expressly designed to safeguard the rights of suspects, defendants, witnesses, and victims, to respond to legal developments and advances in information technology, and to structure criminal proceedings in a lawful, professional, and proportionate manner. In this context, the development of neurotechnology capable of reading neural activity raises serious concerns regarding the principle of nemo tenetur se ipsum accusare, the right to mental privacy, and the principle of a fair trial. This study aims to analyze the constitutional limits on the use of neural activity reading in criminal proceedings and to formulate the juridical conditions for its admissibility within the Indonesian law of evidence. This research employs a normative legal method using statutory, conceptual, and comparative approaches. The findings show that neural activity reading cannot be treated merely as an evidentiary innovation, but must be strictly limited through valid consent, tested scientific validity, judicial oversight, and the prohibition against compelled self-incrimination. Accordingly, the reform of the Code of Criminal Procedure must be understood as a foundation for reaffirming the protection of human dignity in the face of neurotechnology-based evidence.